Tuesday, April 24, 2012

Special Review: Avengers vs X-Men #2


(click to enlarge)
Story : Jason Aaron (script); Jason Aaron, Brian Michael Bendis, Ed Brubaker, Jonathan Hickman & Matt Fraction (story)
Art : John Romita Jr. (pencils), Scott Hanna (inks) and Laura Martin (colours)

After Brian Bendis set the stage for this epic conflict between two of Marvel’s biggest franchises a mere fortnight ago, this week sees the launch of Avengers vs. X-Men #2, with John Romita Jr. continuing on artwork.
The issue mainly features an out and out brawl between the two teams on the shores of Utopia as the Phoenix Force draws nearer to the Earth.


(click to enlarge)
The Story:
All said and done, I really don’t think Jason Aaron was the right person to write this issue. I see Aaron as the type of writer who puts a spotlight firmly on character, however the all-out-hell-breaking-loose nature of this issue and the need to say all that is to be said within the fighting, seems to be more Bendis or Fraction’s forte.
(click to enlarge)
Aaron’s knack for innovation, in the form of plenty of wit and epic-ness, do go a long way in making the issue interesting amidst all the fighting, but it feels a lot like camouflage to mask the fact that this issue does not take the story forward very much. While it certainly is a fun issue and the intention is giving us an action packed issue with plenty of time in the form of 10 issues (and plenty of tie-ins still left) to tell the broader, deeper story, I still can’t shake off the feeling that Aaron’s skills have been wasted for this issue.

The Artwork:
(click to enlarge)
(click to enlarge)
John Romita Jr., on the other hand, has always specialized in action sequences, and while the work looks just a little rushed and the panels a little cluttered, Romita’s immense knack for visual storytelling takes the issue to the ‘win’ category. There’s definitely a very noteable improvement with the art quality from Romita’s recent Avengers run, thanks in part to some much better work on inks and colours.


Final Thoughts: (some spoilers here!)
Now that the violence has been done and dusted with here, it should be interesting to see where some of the story beats initialized in this issue - namely Hope’s escape, the Avengers team in space, The Scarlet Witch’s role in all this and Panther and Storm’s marital troubles - head to, as the event progresses.
(click to enlarge)
Score : 6.8 / 10

No comments:

You might also like

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...